Wednesday, March 22, 2023
No Result
View All Result
Esports Grizzly
  • Home
  • GamesUpdates!
    • Apex Legends
    • Brawl Stars
    • Call of Duty
    • CS:GO
    • Dota 2
    • FIFA
    • Fortnite
    • Free Fire
    • Hearthstone
    • League of Legends (LoL)
    • Magic the Gathering (MTG)
    • Mobile Legends
    • NBA 2K League
    • Overwatch
    • Rainbow 6
    • Rocket League
    • Smite
    • StarCraft II
    • Street Fighter
    • Valorant
    • Wild Rift
    • World of Warcraft (WoW)
  • Esports Betting SitesNew
    • Bitcasino Esports Review | Evil Geniuses’ Home Esports Bookmaker
    • Sportsbet.io Esports Review
    • Cloudbet Esports Review | Is Cloudbet Legit?
    • Betway Esports Review
    • Luckbox Review (2021) – Is Luckbox Esports Safe?
    • GG.Bet Esports Review | League of Legends, Dota 2 and CS:GO
    • Rivalry Esports Review
    • Pinnacle Esports Review
  • Guides
    • Australia Esports Betting Sites
    • Canadian Esports Betting Sites
    • Philippines Esports Betting Sites
    • USA Esports Betting Sites
    • Dogecoin Esports Betting Sites
  • Newsletter
  • About us
  • Contact
Wednesday, March 22, 2023
No Result
View All Result
Esports Grizzly
No Result
View All Result

brawl-stars-characters-and-heroes

Image credit: Supercell

Loot Boxes in Brawl Stars Aren’t Gambling, Rules Judge

in Gaming
January 7, 2022
  • A lawsuit against Apple for allowing Brawl Stars loot boxes has been dismissed by a federal judge
  • Loot boxes have been a sensitive topic for many, and they have often been equated to a form of gambling
  • The judge ruled that it was up to policymakers, not courts to establish whether loot boxes were an actual form of gambling

The tug of war between publishers of games that contain loot boxes and pretty much everyone else has been ongoing for years now. Loot boxes have proven a lucrative form of generating in-game revenue without burdening a game with the bane of the freemium model.

As more games turn to loot boxes for that juicy revenue, though, so are more people objecting to the model. The latest game targeted by a lawsuit against loot boxes became Supercell’s mobile hit, Brawl Stars. The lawsuit named Apple as the defendant for allowing the game on its mobile app store.

Loot Boxes in Brawl Stars Aren’t Tantamount to Gambling

On Tuesday, a San Francisco federal judge sided with Supercell and Apple, denying a class-action lawsuit that targeted the latter, alleging that by allowing Brawl Stars and loot boxes on its App Store, the company was effectively facilitating underage gambling.

The lawsuit, filed by a concerned parent from California, Rebecca Taylor, alleged that children were exposed to loot boxes without understanding the risk profile of those in-game purchases. Many people side with Taylor in general, and loot boxes have often been targeted by governments, parents, and even players themselves.

Most notoriously, EA’s Battlefront loot boxes caused an uproar back in 2018 when the company even issued a rare apology to community members, acknowledging that it “got it wrong.” Loot boxes in Brawl Stars don’t seem to be the same thing, though. In her lawsuit, Taylor explains that her son purchased $25 worth of in-game currency that was then spent on loot boxes.

However, Judge Richard Seeborg from the US District Court in the Northern District of California argued that under current state laws, loot boxes were permitted in California. As a result, it was down to state legislators to prohibit them, not the courts, should they deem it appropriate. Judge Seeborg explained:

“If plaintiffs’ allegations regarding the harmful effects of loot boxes are accurate, the public interest likely lies in seeking legislative remedies.”

Loot Boxes Are aa Broader Issue

Loot boxes have been long criticized for their gambling-like mechanic whereby an item will drop from the digital container, but a consumer would not be able to tell what the item is until they have purchased and opened the box.

After an initial wave of discontent, publishers were obligated to display the odds of each item opening across various jurisdictions. In the United States, there have been calls from individual states to classify loot boxes as gambling and in the United Kingdom, the ongoing Gambling Act Review often hinted at adding loot boxes in the process.

In 2018, a federal judge in Washington State, though, set a precedent by arguing that loot boxes are true “something of value” which resulted in the assets falling under the state’s gambling laws, which made them illegal. This resulted in a $155 million settlement for Big Fish, a game that offered such assets to its consumers.

Meanwhile, Apple’s defense rang familiar. The defendant’s lawyers argued that since Brawl Stars uses virtual currency and the items acquired in-game cannot be used or sold in the real world. In 2016, a massive class-action lawsuit against Valve alleged that the developers were facilitating real-money gambling through skins for Counter-Strike: Global Offensive because the skins could be gambled or sold through third-party websites that Valve had no affiliation with.

Since then, publishers have become far more cautionary when discussing or featuring loot boxes. Apple’s defense was held in court, but Taylor argued that in many ways, loot boxes were akin to slots and that Apple used a “predatory monetization scheme that violates established public policies and constitutes immoral, unethical, or unscrupulous conduct.”

Her argument has failed, but the growing wave of discontent against loot boxes is still simmering.

Tags: AppleBrawl StarsLawsuitLoot Boxes
Alexander TodorovbyAlexander Todorov
Tags: AppleBrawl StarsLawsuitLoot Boxes
Home » Loot Boxes in Brawl Stars Aren’t Gambling, Rules Judge
ShareShareTweetShareSend
league-of-legends-clash-between-champions
Blog

Betting on League of Legends: Top 5 Sites to Wager Using Bitcoin

by Papa Bear
September 15, 2022

Few games have captured the hearts of the wider audiences quite like Riot Games’ masterpiece League of Legends has. The...

Read more
overwatch-female-characters
Opinion

Women in Esports: How Esports Are Moving Towards a More Inclusive Future

by Stefan Velikov
October 25, 2021

Gaming has long been regarded as something reserved for nerdy boys. As times change women join in on the fun...

Read more
v-bucks-currency-in-fortnite
Blog

Bitcoin Esports: Best Crypto Esports Betting Sites

by Alexander Todorov
January 23, 2022

Bitcoin esports betting is on the rise. The idea of placing wagers on your favorite esports teams is an experience...

Read more
Previous Post

The Call of Duty League Might Return to Hosting 12 Teams Per Major

Next Post

Activision Lodges Lawsuit Against EngineOwning over CoD Cheats

Latest and Popular

apex-legends-ea
Gaming

Apex’s Collection Event Rewards Tracker Won’t Be Fixed, Respawn Said

by Stefan Velikov
March 18, 2023
Apex Legends Pros Are Unhappy with Season 14’s Multiplayer Rankin Changes
Gaming

Apex’s Server Issues Make the Game Unplayable

by Stefan Velikov
March 15, 2023
Newcastle, Apex Legends' latest character.
Gaming

Respawn Is Finally Working On Apex’s Infamous “Forced Reload” Hack

by Stefan Velikov
March 6, 2023
Apex Legends Eclipse
Gaming

Here Are Apex Season 16’s Most Popular Legends

by Stoyan Todorov
March 4, 2023

Next Post
call-of-duty-modern-warfare-guerilla-attacking-soldier-with-pickaxe

Activision Lodges Lawsuit Against EngineOwning over CoD Cheats

eSports Grizzly Mobile Dark
eSports Grizzly Mobile Dark

Content Categories

  • Blog
  • Call of Duty
  • College Esports
  • Consoles
  • Cosplay
  • Counter Strike
  • DOTA 2
  • FGC
  • Fortnite
  • Gaming
  • Halo
  • Hearthstone
  • Industry
  • League of Legends
  • Mobile Legends
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Overwatch
  • Popular
  • PUBG
  • Q&A
  • Rainbow Six Siege
  • Rocket League
  • Streamers
  • Uncategorized
  • Valorant

Recent Posts

  • Timofey “⁠interz⁠” Yakushin Leaves Cloud9’s CS:GO Roster
  • TSM’s LCS Team Had the Lowest Budget Heading into 2023 Spring Split, Coach Says
  • Warzone 2’s DMZ Is Dying but Can Be Fixed with a Big Change, Claims Expert

About Esports Grizzly

We bring you the best Premium esports content from around the globe.

Our FREE weekly newsletter

Keep in the loop with our minimalist weekly newsletter. Subscribe today!

GET IN TOUCH

Esports Grizzly reports on the latest industry and gaming intelligence, Want to pitch in? Get in touch!

  • Home
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

© 2021 Esports Grizzly - Your daily BITE of global esports

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Games
    • Apex Legends
    • Brawl Stars
    • Call of Duty
    • CS:GO
    • Dota 2
    • FIFA
    • Fortnite
    • Free Fire
    • Hearthstone
    • League of Legends (LoL)
    • Magic the Gathering (MTG)
    • Mobile Legends
    • NBA 2K League
    • Overwatch
    • Rainbow 6
    • Rocket League
    • Smite
    • StarCraft II
    • Street Fighter
    • Valorant
    • Wild Rift
    • World of Warcraft (WoW)
  • Esports Betting Sites
    • Bitcasino Esports Review | Evil Geniuses’ Home Esports Bookmaker
    • Sportsbet.io Esports Review
    • Cloudbet Esports Review | Is Cloudbet Legit?
    • Betway Esports Review
    • Luckbox Review (2021) – Is Luckbox Esports Safe?
    • GG.Bet Esports Review | League of Legends, Dota 2 and CS:GO
    • Rivalry Esports Review
    • Pinnacle Esports Review
  • Guides
    • Australia Esports Betting Sites
    • Canadian Esports Betting Sites
    • Philippines Esports Betting Sites
    • USA Esports Betting Sites
    • Dogecoin Esports Betting Sites
  • Newsletter
  • About us
  • Contact

© 2021 Esports Grizzly - Your daily BITE of global esports

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.